Individual Details

Paul married Jane P. Blackwell, 12 Feb 1838, Caswell Co NC. She is shown as the daughter of Garland Blackwell and Mary Scott.

Another Internet source shows the marriage as 1828, but I believe 1838 to be correct, given ages of their children in the following censuses:

Copied, not confirmed by me:
1850 Caswell Co., NC Census Page # 363 1372/1375
Watlington, Paul 47 farmer
Jane S. 36
Jonathan B. 10; Mary 6; Sarah J. 5; Virginia 1

1860 Caswell Co., NC Census - Locus Hill #24
Watlington, Paul 59 farmer NC
Jane 45 NC
Jno. B. 20 farmer; M. E. 16 female; S. J. 14 female; Amanda 9; F. P. 7; L. A. 5 female; W. P. 3 male

1870 Caswell Co., Census Locust Hill # 12/12
Watlington, Paul 67 farmer
Jane 54
John 27 farm labor; Mary 23; Amanda 17; Fanny 15; Laura12
Rice Thomas 53

1880 Caswell Co., NC - Locust Hill
Name: Paul Watlington 74 farmer born abt 1806 in NC (Father in Va. mother NC)
Jane S. Watlington 65 wife
Francis P. Watlington 23 daughter
Thomas G. Rice 63 boarder
Eliza Watlington 42 black [servant]
Albert Watlington 11 black [servant]

Caswell Co, NC Estate Files. FamilySearch.org
Paul Watlington, 1884. 28 pages
Inventory and Sale held 15-16 November 1882. John B. Watlington & James S. Blackwell, Executors.
Petition from the heirs of Paul Watlington by John B. Watlington, Fannie P. Watlington, Thomas Dailey & wife Amanda B. Dailey, Ansel White & wife Sarah J. White, W. W. Siddle & wife Laura A. Siddle, Robt, Gwyn, and Mamie Gwyn & R. C. Gwyn, minor children of Mary E. Gwyn, dec'd. Notes that Paul died sometime in the year 1882, leaving the listed heirs. Mary E. Gwyn had died in 1883 leaving her two children as her heirs at law. Each child to have 1/6 share accounting for certain advancements mentioned in the will of Paul Watlington. Robert Gwyn being entitled to a life interest in the share of Mary E. Gwyn with the remainder to the minors Mamie & Robert C. Gwyn. The lands include the homestead adjoining lands of the late John Blackwell, Geo. Dailey & others containing 265 acres, a half interest in a 12 acre tract adjoining the homestead, the life interest of the widow Elizabeth Jones in a tract of 30 acres which adjoins Geo. Dailey & others, a tract of 45 acres adjoining lands of John B. Watlington, John Siddle Sr. The lands had been sold but the heirs requested an equitable division by the court. Documents include the courts decision which included the payment to Robert Gwyn for his life estate.

Birth	Ca 1803	Caswell County, North Carolina
Death	Bef Nov 1882	Caswell County, North Carolina

Father	Armistead Watlington (1766 - 1840)
Mother	Mary Brookes (1766 - 1840)
Sibling	Jonathan Brooks Watlington (1791 - 1844)
Sibling	Edward Watlington (1794 - )
Sibling	Armistead Watlington (1796 - 1869)
Sibling	James Watlington (1797 - 1880)
Sibling	Thomas Watlington (1799 - )
Sibling	Emanuel Watlington (1801 - 1882)
Sibling	Mary Watlington (1807 - )
Sibling	Living