Individual Details

Results of Y-DNA shows that Thomspon and Presley Carter descendants have similar Y=DNA. Haplogroup is R1b1. However, it does NOT seem to be the Presley Carter who is a brother to Thompson - perhaps a descendant of the brother Spencer instead.. Here is a GEDCOM from a descendant of Thompson Carter.

Descendants of Thompson Carter
1 Thompson Carter b: 08 August 1808 in Pittsylvania County, Virginia d: 05 May 1857 in Madison County, Tennessee
. +Nancy W. Yancey b: 06 April 1805 in Halifax County, Virginia m: 3 January 1831 in Halifax County, Virginia d: 12 November 1858 in Madison County, Tennessee
............. 2 William Y(ancey) Carter b: 24 May 1837 in Halifax County, Virginia or Madison County, Tennessee d: 29 May 1864 in Madison County, Tennessee
................. +Mary Ann Lackey b: Abt. 1836 in Madison County, Tennessee m: 12 March 1859 in Madison County, Tennessee d: Bef. 1876 in Madison County, Tennessee
............................. 3 William Thomas A(lexander) Carter b: 1861 in Medon, Madison County, Tennessee d: 19 August 1936 in Jackson, Madison County, Tennessee
................................. +Mary Alexander Spencer b: 24 March 1861 in Jackson, Madison County, Tennessee m: 24 January 1884 in Jackson, Madison County, Tennessee d: 25 March 1948 in Jackson, Madison County, Tennessee
............................................. 4 Lee Mitchell Carter, Sr. b: 17 October 1886 in Jackson, Madison County, Tennessee d: 18 June 1966 in Greenville, Washington County, Mississippi
................................................. +Bertha Eliza Turner b: 31 August 1893 in Belzoni, Washington County, Mississippi m: 07 September 1921 in Belzoni, Humphreys County, Mississippi d: 18 January 1981 in Belzoni, Humphreys County, Mississippi
............................................................. 5 Lee Mitchell Carter, Jr. b: 05 October 1922 in Belzoni, Humphreys County, Mississippi d: 07 June 1998 in At home, Pine Bluff, Jefferson County, Arkansas
................................................................. +Billie Roxine Tomlinson b: Private m: Private
............................................................................ 6 William Tomlinson Carter b: Private


Here is part of a report on descendants of the Presley Carter whose Y-DNA is similar to that of Thompson Carter. I believe there are some serious problems with this genealogy as I also have George Carter, not Richard, married to Frances Neale....George & Frances were parents of Thompson, a Presley, and a Spencer.
Descendants of Presley Carter
Generation 1
1. PRESLEY1 CARTER was born in 1720 in Lancaster, Lancaster, Virginia.
Presley Carter had the following child:
2. i. RICHARD2 CARTER was born in 1745 in Stafford County, Virginia, USA. He died in
1786 in Halifax County, Virginia, USA. He married FRANCES NEALE. She was born in
1750 in Virginia, United States. She died in 1800 in Pittsylvania, Virginia, United
States.
Generation 2
2. RICHARD2 CARTER (Presley1) was born in 1745 in Stafford County, Virginia, USA. He died in 1786
in Halifax County, Virginia, USA. He married FRANCES NEALE. She was born in 1750 in Virginia,
United States. She died in 1800 in Pittsylvania, Virginia, United States.
Richard Carter and Frances Neale had the following child:
3. i. SPENCER3 CARTER was born on 11 Sep 1773 in Caroline County, Virginia. He died
in Pittsylvania County, Virginia, USA. He married VERLINDA LUCAS on 18 Dec 1804
in Halifax, Virginia. She was born in 1773 in Caroline, Virginia, USA. She died in
1825 in Pittsylvania, Virginia, USA.
Generation 3
3. SPENCER3 CARTER (Richard2, Presley1) was born on 11 Sep 1773 in Caroline County, Virginia. He died in Pittsylvania County, Virginia, USA. He married VERLINDA LUCAS on 18 Dec 1804 in Halifax,
Virginia. She was born in 1773 in Caroline, Virginia, USA. She died in 1825 in Pittsylvania, Virginia, USA.
Spencer Carter and Verlinda Lucas had the following child:
4. i. ALEXANDER4 CARTER was born in 1819 in Pittsylvania County, Virginia, USA. He
died in 1858. He married MARTHA ANN LYONS on 30 May 1840 in Pittsylvania,
Virginia, USA, daughter of William Lyons and Eleanor Hightower Anderson. She
was born on 10 May 1820 in Pittsylvania County, Virginia, USA. She died on 13 Feb
1895 in Rockingham Co, North Carolina, USA.
Generation 4
4. ALEXANDER4 CARTER (Spencer3, Richard2, Presley1) was born in 1819 in Pittsylvania County, Virginia, USA. He died in 1858. He married MARTHA ANN LYONS on 30 May 1840 in Pittsylvania, Virginia, USA, daughter of William Lyons and Eleanor Hightower Anderson. She was born on 10 May 1820 in Pittsylvania County, Virginia, USA. She died on 13 Feb 1895 in Rockingham Co, North Carolina, USA.
Notes for Martha Ann Lyons:
MarthaLyonCarter
http://trees.ancestry.com/rd?f=image&guid=13b543a9-9a93-49c2-a4e7-9a1ca8679b9&tid=92560 62&pid=-784950655
Alexander Carter and Martha Ann Lyons had the following children:
5. i. WILLIAM SPENCER5 CARTER was born on 31 May 1841 in Pittsylvania County,
Virginia, USA. He died on 14 Jun 1896 in Pittsylvania County, Virginia, USA. He
married CORNELIA LEE GUERRANT on 05 Sep 1863 in Rockingham, North Carolina,
daughter of Daniel Ellington Guerrant and Malinda Ann Vernon Stubblefield. She
was born on 16 Feb 1845 in Ruffin, North Carolina, USA. She died on 10 Mar 1926
in Ruffin, North Carolina.
ii. ELIZABETH JANE CARTER was born in Jul 1843 in Pittsylvania County, Virginia.
iii. JOHN ALEXANDER CARTER was born in 1846 in Pittsylvania County, Virginia. He died
in 1887 in Pittsylvania, Virginia, United States.
iv. JAMES HERITAGE CARTER was born in 1850 in Pittsylvania County. He died in 1885
in Pittsylvania, Virginia, United States.
v. MARY ELLEN CARTER was born in 1856 in Pittsylvania County, Virginia. She died in
1883 in Pittsylvania, Virginia, United States.

Father	George Carter ( - 1785)
Mother	Frances Neale ( - )
Sibling	Richard Alexander Carter ( - )
Sibling	John Carter ( - 1799)
Sibling	George Carter ( - 1829)
Sibling	Presley Carter (1765 - )
Sibling	Levin Carter (1757 - )
Sibling	Charles Ewell Carter (1775 - 1874)
Sibling	Spencer Carter ( - 1858)
Sibling	Mary Carter ( - )
Sibling	Margaret Carter ( - )
Sibling	Elizabeth Carter ( - )
Sibling	Sarah Carter ( - )