| Father | Pvt Noah Warnstaff (1833 - 1909) |
| Mother | Sarah Mariah Elizabeth "Maria" Wheeler (1832 - 1894) |
| Sibling | James Jasper "Jape" Warnstaff (1856 - 1895) |
| Sibling | Jarvis W Warnstaff (1856 - 1942) |
| Sibling | Martha Josephine "Jossie" Warnstaff (1860 - 1928) |
| Sibling | Robert Wornstaff (1860 - 1860) |
| Sibling | Stephen A. Douglas Warnstaff (1861 - 1929) |
| Sibling | Elvetta "Vet" Warnstaff (1864 - 1942) |
| Sibling | Emma Orselia Warnstaff (1865 - 1901) |
| Sibling | William Henry M. "Hull" Warnstaff (1866 - 1915) |
| Sibling | John Lewis "Lew" Warnstaff (1867 - 1959) |
| Sibling | Laura Merissa Warnstaff (1870 - 1968) |
| Sibling | Noah Marion "Dodge" Warnstaff (1872 - 1946) |
| Sibling | Harvey Thomas "Harve" Warnstaff (1874 - 1920) |