| Father | Isaac Newcomer (1809 - 1895) |
| Mother | Elizabeth Emmert (1812 - 1895) |
| Sibling | Ann Maria Newcomer (1834 - 1871) |
| Sibling | Benjamin Emmert Newcomer (1835 - 1836) |
| Sibling | Elizabeth F. Newcomer (1836 - 1920) |
| Sibling | Josiah Newcomer (1838 - 1841) |
| Sibling | Abner Newcomer (1839 - 1931) |
| Sibling | Melchor Snively Newcomer (1842 - 1920) |
| Sibling | Mary Catherine Newcomer (1844 - 1853) |
| Sibling | Martin D. Newcomer (1846 - 1894) |
| Sibling | Orpah Ellen Newcomer (1847 - ) |
| Sibling | Emma Jane Newcomer (1849 - 1904) |
| Sibling | Amanda Emmert Newcomer (1851 - 1853) |
| Sibling | William Franklin Newcomer (1854 - 1854) |
| Sibling | Samuel Isaac Newcomer (1856 - 1947) |