Individual Details

William or "Bill Goodman" is said to have married Manda Cotton.
In 1850, there was an Amanda Cotton, age 10, daughter of John & Eliza, living next door to Asa Goodman. Archibald was at that time, age 11.

A William F. Goodman, born 1853, is said to have married Elizabeth Miller, 23 Jan 1885, Benton Co TN. He has been placed here as a child of Arch & Sarah by some. I think he belongs elsewhere.

But here is still another possible William, called Bill, born 1850.
This is likely William "Bill", another son of Asa; on the next page from John L. However, if this identification is correct, Celia is a second wife - his wife was Elizabeth in 1880. Another research gives William F. Goodman, married Elizabeth Miller, 23 Jan 1885 in Benton Co but gives his birth as 1858.
1900 Census. Civil Dist 1, Benton Co, TN Hh 123
William Goodman, b. Jan 1850, age 50, married 10 yr, b. TN, parents born TN, farmer
Celia, wife, b. Jan 1851, age 49, had 1 child, still living, b. TN
Grady, nephew, b. Feb 1898, age 2.
Living in the household just before William Goodman, there is a Mary A. Goodman, designated as "Aunt". She was born Jan 1852, age 48, marked as "D" for divorced and living with John and Willie Daniel and their six-year-old son, Otis.

Birth

1853

Tennessee

Father	Archibald William Goodman (1838 - )
Mother	Sarah Ann Goodman (1834 - )
Sibling	Robert Harvey Goodman (1859 - )
Sibling	Granville Goodman (1864 - )
Sibling	Liza A. Goodman (1865 - )
Sibling	Alabama Duncan "Bama" Goodman (1872 - 1965)