| Father | John BRUMBAUGH (1804 - 1877) |
| Mother | Catherine/Katharine E. SHINGLER (1810 - 1886) |
| Sibling | Ephraim BRUMBAUGH (1827 - 1829) |
| Sibling | Joseph BRUMBAUGH (1829 - 1923) |
| Sibling | Jacob BRUMBAUGH (1831 - 1916) |
| Sibling | John BRUMBAUGH (1832 - 1908) |
| Sibling | Samuel Sanford BRUMBAUGH (1834 - 1915) |
| Sibling | Elizabeth BRUMBAUGH (1835 - 1845) |
| Sibling | Susan BRUMBAUGH (1837 - 1850) |
| Sibling | Alfred BRUMBAUGH (1839 - 1910) |
| Sibling | Andrew BRUMBAUGH (1840 - 1865) |
| Sibling | William W. BRUMBAUGH (1842 - 1844) |
| Sibling | Mary BRUMBAUGH (1844 - ) |
| Sibling | Margaret BRUMBAUGH (1846 - 1848) |
| Sibling | Henry BRUMBAUGH (1848 - 1873) |
| Sibling | Michael BRUMBAUGH (1850 - ) |
| Sibling | Jeremiah "Jerry" BRUMBAUGH (1852 - ) |