| Father | Henry PITSENBARGER (1805 - 1870) |
| Mother | Elizabeth MILLER (1810 - 1863) |
| Sibling | Susanna PITSENBARGER (1829 - 1893) |
| Sibling | Jacob S. PITSENBARGER (1831 - 1860) |
| Sibling | Elizabeth PITSENBARGER (1833 - 1912) |
| Sibling | Margaret PITSENBARGER (1835 - ) |
| Sibling | Sarah Ann PITSENBARGER (1840 - 1911) |
| Sibling | Manassah M. PITSENBARGER (1843 - 1940) |
| Sibling | Ephraim PITSENBARGER (1845 - 1845) |
| Sibling | Mary Margaret PITSENBARGER (1847 - 1939) |
| Sibling | Phebe Ella PITSENBARGER (1850 - 1922) |
| Sibling | Barbara Anna PITSENBARGER (1852 - 1914) |