| Father | Elder David BRUMBAUGH (1803 - 1883) |
| Mother | Elizabeth BOWMAN (1803 - 1867) |
| Sibling | Barbara Bowman BRUMBAUGH (1827 - 1899) |
| Sibling | Elizabeth BRUMBAUGH (1828 - 1904) |
| Sibling | Catharine BRUMBAUGH (1830 - 1910) |
| Sibling | Mary "Polly" BRUMBAUGH (1831 - 1901) |
| Sibling | Susan/Susannah BRUMBAUGH (1833 - 1895) |
| Sibling | John B. BRUMBAUGH (1835 - 1890) |
| Sibling | David BRUMBAUGH (1837 - 1907) |
| Sibling | Daniel BRUMBAUGH (1838 - 1838) |
| Sibling | Lavinia BRUMBAUGH (1839 - 1839) |
| Sibling | Jacob BRUMBAUGH (1840 - 1840) |
| Sibling | Benjamin BRUMBAUGH (1841 - 1922) |
| Sibling | Margaret "Peggy" BRUMBAUGH (1841 - 1922) |
