| Father | Charles Edward NININGER (1847 - 1919) |
| Mother | Sarah Ann RHOADES (1853 - 1924) |
| Sibling | Margaret Catherine "Cassie" NININGER (1871 - 1945) |
| Sibling | Mary Jane NININGER (1873 - 1873) |
| Sibling | George Christian NININGER (1874 - 1874) |
| Sibling | James Earnest NININGER (1875 - 1899) |
| Sibling | Louis Franklin NININGER (1878 - 1882) |
| Sibling | Amos Charles NININGER (1881 - 1962) |
| Sibling | William Ananias NININGER (1883 - 1884) |
| Sibling | Minnie Ellen NININGER (1885 - 1896) |
| Sibling | Sarah Elizabeth "Sadie" NININGER (1887 - 1971) |
| Sibling | Nettie Virginia NININGER (1890 - 1964) |