| Father | Rev. George Wineland BRUMBAUGH (1827 - 1916) |
| Mother | Elizabeth S. NICODEMUS (1830 - 1908) |
| Sibling | Susan BRUMBAUGH (1850 - 1861) |
| Sibling | Harriet Nicodemus BRUMBAUGH (1851 - 1943) |
| Sibling | Mary Nicodemus BRUMBAUGH (1853 - 1943) |
| Sibling | Andrew BRUMBAUGH (1856 - 1861) |
| Sibling | Levi Nicodemus BRUMBAUGH (1858 - 1937) |
| Sibling | Keturah BRUMBAUGH (1860 - 1865) |
| Sibling | Reuben Nicodemus BRUMBAUGH (1862 - 1903) |
| Sibling | George Durbin BRUMBAUGH (1866 - 1935) |
| Sibling | Annie BRUMBAUGH (1869 - 1932) |
| Sibling | Margaret Nicodemus "Maggie" BRUMBAUGH (1871 - 1945) |
| Sibling | Frank Nicodemus BRUMBAUGH (1876 - 1945) |