| Father | Joseph S. Butterbaugh METZGER (1821 - 1899) |
| Mother | Elizabeth "Bessie" STUDEBAKER (1827 - 1900) |
| Sibling | Mary A. METZGER (1846 - 1897) |
| Sibling | Abraham Studebaker METZGER (1848 - 1925) |
| Sibling | Elizabeth Studebaker METZGER (1850 - 1915) |
| Sibling | Isaac Studebaker METZGER (1852 - 1936) |
| Sibling | Jacob Studebaker METZGER (1855 - 1856) |
| Sibling | Phoebe Studebaker METZGER (1857 - 1940) |
| Sibling | Samuel Studebaker METZGER (1859 - 1861) |
| Sibling | Rebecca Studebaker METZGER (1863 - 1932) |
| Sibling | Joseph Studebaker METZGER (1865 - 1937) |
| Sibling | John Studebaker METZGER (1868 - 1933) |
| Sibling | Anna Studebaker METZGER (1871 - 1908) |