| Father | Nimrod McElroy (1825 - 1903) |
| Mother | Elizabeth Newby (1827 - 1867) |
| Sibling | Sarah Ellen McElroy (1845 - 1887) |
| Sibling | Sarah Ellen McElroy (1846 - 1866) |
| Sibling | George Washington McElroy (1848 - 1880) |
| Sibling | Penina Jane McElroy (1849 - 1927) |
| Sibling | Emily Jane McElroy (1852 - 1884) |
| Sibling | Samuel Wilkenson McElroy (1852 - 1901) |
| Sibling | Mary Ann McElroy (1854 - 1954) |
| Sibling | Adam Pascal McElroy (1860 - 1951) |
| Sibling | Amanda A. McElroy (1862 - 1875) |
| Sibling | Margaret McElroy (1864 - 1864) |
| Sibling | Walter Scott McElroy (1866 - ) |
| Sibling | William Nimrod McElroy (1867 - 1868) |