| Father | Leonard Evarts (1797 - 1872) |
| Mother | Sabra Parmelee (1804 - ) |
| Sibling | Polly Maria Evarts (1824 - 1865) |
| Sibling | Washington Irving Evarts (1827 - 1900) |
| Sibling | Joel Atwater Evarts (1828 - 1899) |
| Sibling | Nathan Garner Evarts (1831 - 1880) |
| Sibling | Wilbur Sylvester Evarts (1834 - 1916) |
| Sibling | Joseph W. Evarts (1836 - 1864) |
| Sibling | Sabre Artemiasia Evarts (1838 - 1914) |
| Sibling | Martha Ann Evarts (1839 - 1912) |
| Sibling | Achsah Leantine Evarts (1844 - 1882) |
| Sibling | Victor Jutsan Evarts (1844 - ) |
| Sibling | Zeno Parmelee Evarts (1848 - ) |