| Father | Daniel Albert Conatser (1797 - 1840) |
| Mother | Sarah Esther Easter Keith (1801 - 1884) |
| Sibling | James Harvey Conatser (1820 - 1883) |
| Sibling | William Boyd Conatser (1822 - 1882) |
| Sibling | Daniel Keith Conatser (1823 - 1879) |
| Sibling | John Albert Conatser (1826 - 1826) |
| Sibling | Henry Alexander Conatser (1828 - 1904) |
| Sibling | Frank A. Conatser (1830 - ) |
| Sibling | Ruth Ellen Conatser (1832 - 1904) |
| Sibling | Caroline Conatser (1834 - 1917) |
| Sibling | George Conatser (1835 - ) |
| Sibling | Benjamin Conatser (1835 - ) |
| Sibling | Margaret Conatser (1838 - ) |
| Sibling | Dorinda Conatser (1840 - 1911) |