| Birth | 30 Mar 1826 | Fort Seybert, Pendleton, Virginia | | | |
| Occupation | 1847 | two days of plowing for neighbor - Fort Seybert, Pendleton, Virginia | | | |
| Alt name | 1850 | Peter P. Wansturf | | | |
| Occupation | 1850 | US Postmaster - Sweedland Valley, Botetourt, Virginia | | | |
| Residence | 1850 | Pendleton, Louisa, Virginia | | | |
| Miscellaneous | 28 Nov 1858 | Warnstaffs were mentioned 10x in Elder John Kline's diary - Warnstaff's tanyard, Pendleton, Louisa, Virginia | | | |
| Alt name | 1860 | Peter Wanstaff | | | |
| Alt name | 1860 | Peter Wansturff | | | |
| Slave Owner | 1860 | Farmer - Pendleton, Louisa, Virginia | | | |
| Residence | 1860 | Rev Kline visited with Peter Warnstaff (7 miles) take dinner with him and his kind mother & sister. - Pendleton, Louisa, Virginia | | | |
| Census-shared | 5 Jun 1860 | (Catharine Häefner Pope) Franklin Town, Pendleton, West Virginia | | | |
| Census | 11 Jun 1860 | Slave Inhabitant Schedule, Pendleton, Louisa, Virginia | | | |
| Military | 1861 - 1865 | Civil War - charged with Treason against the US Govt - 28th Ohio Reg Infantry, Virginia | | |  |
| Military | 1863 | Virginia | | | |
| Residence | 1870 | Pendleton, Louisa, Virginia | | | |
| Alt name | 12 Jul 1870 | Peter P. Wansturf | | | |
| Occupation | 12 Jul 1870 | Farmer - Pendleton, Louisa, Virginia | | | |
| Census-shared | 12 Jul 1870 | (Catharine Häefner Pope) Oak Flats Post Office, Bethel, Highland, Virginia | | | |
| Occupation | 10 Jul 1871 | Commissioners Appointed - Pendleton, Louisa, Virginia | | | |
| Residence | 1880 | Pendleton, Louisa, Virginia | | | |
| Census | 15 Jun 1880 | Bethel, Highland, Virginia | | | |
| Probate-shared | 4 Nov 1892 | (Catharine Häefner Pope) Pendleton, Louisa, Virginia | | | |
| Residence | 1900 | Pendleton, Louisa, Virginia | | | |
| Death | Dec 1904 | Fort Seybert, Pendleton, Virginia | | | |
| Burial | Dec 1904 | Warnstaff Cemetery #14, Fort Seybert, Pendleton, Virginia | | | |
| Alt name | 30 Dec 1904 | Peter P. Warnstaff | | | |
| Probate | 30 Dec 1904 | Probate, Fort Seybert, Pendleton, Virginia | | | |
| Alt name | | Peter Warnsturff | | | |
| Military | | Confederate Estates, Jefferson, Alabama | | | |
