| Spouse | Sarah Johnson (1796 - 1871) |
| Child | Humphrey Pleasant "H. P." McBrayer (1810 - 1895) |
| Child | James F. McBrayer (1814 - ) |
| Child | William McBrayer (1815 - ) |
| Child | Samuel Buncombe "Sam" McBrayer Esq (1815 - 1902) |
| Child | Jane Ann McBrayer (1822 - 1905) |
| Child | Jonathan McBrayer (1826 - 1870) |
| Child | Rebekah McBrayer (1827 - ) |
| Child | Harriet Malinda McBrayer (1828 - 1915) |
| Child | Mary R. McBrayer (1830 - 1903) |
| Child | Nancy Urena McBrayer (1830 - 1914) |
| Child | Sarah Elizabeth McBrayer (1833 - 1905) |
| Child | Hugh Cato McBrayer (1837 - ) |
| Child | Martha Matilda McBrayer (1838 - 1910) |