| Father | Benjamin MONTANYE Jr. (1781 - 1848) |
| Mother | Theodosia CLARK (1782 - 1858) |
| Sibling | Thomas B. MONTANYE (1806 - 1879) |
| Sibling | Samuel C. MONTANYE (1808 - 1871) |
| Sibling | Deborah MONTANYE (1811 - 1864) |
| Sibling | Elizabeth MONTANYE (1813 - 1896) |
| Sibling | Robert Dela MONTANYE (1816 - 1895) |
| Sibling | Lucinda J. MONTANYE (1818 - 1918) |
| Sibling | John D. MONTANYE (1821 - 1892) |
| Sibling | Infant son MONTANYE (1823 - 1823) |
| Sibling | Isaac Vredenburgh MONTANYE (1825 - 1906) |
| Sibling | Henry B. MONTANYE (1827 - 1887) |
| Sibling | Esther MONTANYE (1830 - 1838) |
| Sibling | Benjamin Franklin "Frank" MONTANYE (1832 - 1909) |