| Father | George Frederick Motteler (1831 - 1919) |
| Mother | Cilicia Taylor (1835 - 1920) |
| Sibling | Alva "Taylor" Motteler (1857 - 1951) |
| Sibling | Henry Elisha "H. E." Motteler (1861 - 1951) |
| Sibling | Ann Adelice Motteler (1863 - 1930) |
| Sibling | William Merley "Will" Motteler (1867 - 1953) |
| Sibling | Frank Thurman "F. T." Motteler (1872 - 1943) |
| Sibling | Rosa M. "Rose" Motteler (1875 - 1888) |
| Sibling | Llewellyn "Lou" Motteler (1876 - 1933) |
| Sibling | Clintion Illinois "C. I." Motteler (1879 - 1956) |
| Sibling | Delmore Bronson "D. B." Motteler (1881 - 1943) |