| Birth | Mar 1834 | Vermont or Canada | | | |
| Birth | Mar 1836 | Vermont or Canada | | | |
| Occupation | 11 Jul 1860 | tanner with a personal estate valued at $400 - Buckland, Franklin County, Massachusetts | | | |
| Residence | 11 Jul 1860 | in the Eliza Elmer household - Buckland, Franklin County, Massachusetts | | | |
| Marriage | 13 Dec 1860 | Shelburne, Franklin County, Massachusetts - Climera MALLORY | | | |
| Occupation | 7 Jul 1862 | farmer - Buckland, Franklin County, Massachusetts | | | |
| Religion | 1865 | and Mary were members of First Presbyterian Church where Rev. Albert E. Barnes was the minister - Philadelphia, Philadelphia County, Pennsylvania | | | |
| Marriage | 1865 | Philadelphia, Philadelphia County, Pennsylvania - Mary Williams HOWES | | | |
| Residence (family) | 14 Jul 1870 | and he owned real estate valued at $13,000 and a personal estate valued at $2,000 - Ashfield, Franklin County, Massachusetts - Mary Williams HOWES | | | |
| Residence (family) | 7 Jun 1871 | Brooklyn, Kings County, New York - Mary Williams HOWES | | | |
| Religion | | and Mary were members of Plymouth Church where Rev. Henry Ward Beecher was the minister - Brooklyn, Kings County, New York | | | |
| Miscellaneous | 25 May 1874 | bought a foreclosed house on Seventh Street, east of Fifth Ave, from G. M. Stevens for $2,900 - Brooklyn, Kings County, New York | | | |
| Residence (family) | 1877 | at 359 Seventh Street - Brooklyn, Kings County, New York - Mary Williams HOWES | | | |
| Occupation | Mar 1879 | cotton broker with John Drummond at Drummond & Goddard located at 124 Pearl Street - New York, New York County, New York | | | |
| Occupation | 9 Jun 1880 | cotton broker - Brooklyn, Kings County, New York | | | |
| Residence (family) | 9 Jun 1880 | at 359 Seventh Street - Brooklyn, Kings County, New York - Mary Williams HOWES | | | |
| Residence | 1881 | at 359 7th and was a broker - Brooklyn, Kings County, New York | | | |
| Residence (family) | May 1889 | Tacoma, Pierce County, Washington - Mary Williams HOWES | | | |
| Residence (family) | 1895 | at 757 D Street - Tacoma, Pierce County, Washington - Mary Williams HOWES | | | |
| Occupation | 1 Jun 1900 | plumber - Tacoma, Pierce County, Washington | | | |
| Residence (family) | 1 Jun 1900 | at 757 South D Street in a rented house - Tacoma, Pierce County, Washington - Mary Williams HOWES | | | |
| Residence (family) | Bet 1905 and 1907 | with their son, Dr. Frederick Leland Goddard, - Sanitarium, Sitka County, Alaska - Mary Williams HOWES | | | |
| Residence (family) | 14 Jan 1910 | as boarders at the Sitka or Goddard Hot Springs - Sanitarium, Sitka County, Alaska - Mary Williams HOWES | | | |
| Death | 16 Dec 1912 | from senility - Sitka Hot Springs, Sitka County, Alaska | | | |
| Miscellaneous | 20 Dec 1912 | was deceased and his remains were shipped from Sitka Hot Spings on the "Georgia" with his son, Fred, - Juneau, Juneau County, Alaska | | | |
| Burial | Aft 20 Dec 1912 | next to his wife, Mary W. Howes Goddard, - Tacoma, Pierce County, Washington | | | |