| Father | Benjamin Colton Sr. (1695 - 1770) |
| Mother | Elizabeth Pynchon (1702 - 1776) |
| Sibling | Benjamin Colton Jr. (1722 - 1808) |
| Sibling | Charles Colton (1724 - 1809) |
| Sibling | Moses Colton (1726 - 1771) |
| Sibling | Gideon Colton (1728 - 1823) |
| Sibling | Elizabeth Colton (1730 - ) |
| Sibling | Bathshua Colton (1732 - ) |
| Sibling | Isaac Colton (1734 - 1812) |
| Sibling | William Colton (1736 - 1813) |
| Sibling | Margaret Colton (1738 - ) |
| Sibling | Hannah Colton (1740 - ) |
| Sibling | Aaron Colton (1744 - 1821) |
| Sibling | Rhoda Colton (1748 - ) |
| Sibling | Edward Colton (1750 - ) |
| Sibling | Reuben Colton (1752 - 1757) |
