| Father | Martin Witter (1821 - ) |
| Mother | Lydia Eikenberry (1825 - 1895) |
| Sibling | Elizabeth Witter (1844 - 1936) |
| Sibling | George Witter (1845 - 1924) |
| Sibling | Peter Witter (1851 - 1858) |
| Sibling | Mary Jane Witter (1855 - 1859) |
| Sibling | Sarah Ellen Witter (1856 - 1858) |
| Sibling | Abraham Witter (1857 - 1908) |
| Sibling | Frances Witter (1858 - 1928) |
| Sibling | Martin Witter (1858 - 1864) |
| Sibling | Emma Witter (1862 - 1915) |
| Sibling | John Emmet Witter (1867 - 1871) |
| Sibling | Margaret Witter (1870 - 1930) |
| Sibling | Joe Witter ( - ) |
| Sibling | Henry Witter ( - ) |