| Father | Daniel Eikenberry Senior (1799 - 1859) |
| Mother | Sarah Kingery ( - ) |
| Sibling | John Eikenberry (1822 - 1876) |
| Sibling | Joseph Eikenberry (1824 - 1880) |
| Sibling | Baltzer Eikenberry (1825 - 1903) |
| Sibling | Abraham Eikenberry (1830 - 1870) |
| Sibling | Jacob Eikenberry (1832 - 1899) |
| Sibling | Peter Eikenberry (1834 - 1864) |
| Sibling | Henry Eikenberry (1836 - 1845) |
| Sibling | Phillip Eikenberry (1839 - 1846) |
| Sibling | Samuel Eikenberry (1841 - 1916) |
| Sibling | Andrew Eikenberry (1844 - 1937) |
| Sibling | Daniel Eikenberry Junior (1844 - 1892) |
| Sibling | Aaron Eikenberry (1846 - 1911) |
| Sibling | Martin Eikenberry (1848 - 1886) |
| Sibling | Sarah Elizabeth Eikenberry (1849 - 1860) |
