| Residence | 1874 | Putnam, Ohio, United States | | | |
| Birth | 14 Mar 1874 | Riley Township, Putnam, Ohio, United States | | | |
| Residence | 1880 | Riley Township, Putnam, Ohio, United States | | | |
| Residence | 1900 | Pandora, Riley Township, Putnam, Ohio, United States | | | |
| Marriage | 14 Mar 1905 | Indiana, Pennsylvania, United States - Mabel A. Armstrong | | | |
| Residence | 1910 | Riley Township, Putnam, Ohio, United States | | | |
| Military Draft Registration | 1917 - 1918 | Indiana, Pennsylvania, United States | | | |
| Residence | 1920 | Green Township, Indiana, Pennsylvania, United States | | | |
| Residence | 1930 | Green Township, Indiana, Pennsylvania, United States | | | |
| Residence | 1935 | Same House | | | |
| Residence | 1940 | Green Township, Indiana, Pennsylvania, United States | | | |
| Burial | 1955 | Hazelet Cemetery, Cherry Tree, Indiana, Pennsylvania, United States | | | |
| Death | 29 Sep 1955 | | | | |
| Christen | | Putnam, Ohio, United States | | | |
| FIND-A-GRAVE | | https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/77773989/orton-j_-cartwright | | | |