Individual Details

The Comstock book says this Hannah married James Gardner of Smithfield. No date given. Database on ancestry show the marriage to James Gardner as circa 1790; then a marriage to David Hutchinson circa 1795.
The database gives Hannah's death as 1816, but children born to her as late as 1821, including the Hiram that David & his second wife were living with in 1850.

In RI vital records there is a married between James Gardner and Sally Olney, 31 Jan 1793.


Here is an old inquiry:
From: "Bob Dubel"
Subject: David Hutchinson, b 1770, m Hannah Comstock
Date: Sun, 23 Aug 1998 14:30:06 -0700

I would like to learn whether this David Hutchinson's 1st wife Hannah
Comstock was my husband's ancestor or whether a later wife Unknown was his
ancestor. How many children did Hannah have?

Family tradition says it is possible that David and Hannah moved from VT to
RI before moving to Ontario, Canada. Or did Hannah die in RI? There is
supposed to be a will in RI. Family tradition also says when David was
elderly he married Mrs. Bugbee.

David Hutchinson, b 18 Feb 1770 Chester, Windsor Co VT, d after 1815 Leeds
Co, Ontario, Canada? or d 26 Jan 1853 Hammond, St.Lawrence Co NY? m ca 1796
RI? to Hannah Comstock, b ca 1770 MA? CT? VT?, d before 1796 Leeds Co,
Ontario, Canada? or d RI (supposed to be a will in RI). David had 9
children:

i. John, b ca 1797, m Sarah Stundfaut.
ii. Bryon-Cyrus, b ca 1798, m 9 June 1823 Brockville, Ontario, Canada to
Sarah Mallory.
iii. David, b 4 Mar 1799 Escott, Leeds Co, Ontario, Canada, d 10 July 1875,
m 1818 Lavinia Brooker.
iv. Noah, b 1806, m Abigail (Abi) Mallory.
v. Joab, b ca 1807.
vi. Ruthelia, b 4 Jan 1809 or 4 Jan 1802, m Robert Taylor.
FindAGrave - b. 4 Jan 1803, d. 23 Aug 1882, Escott, Ontario, Canada. Buried Union Cemetery, Lansdowne, Onatario, Canada
vii. Keturah, b ca 1810, res Quibbon, Ontario (means Quabbin, Escott Twp?),
m Mr. Fergusen.
viii. Lydia, b ca 1812, m 25 Feb 1830 Brockville, Leeds Co, Ontario, Canada
to James Benson.
ix. Wellington (our ancestor), b 7 July 1815, d 7 Jun 1860 Leeds Co,
Ontario, Canada, m 16 Sep 1837 Ontario, Canada to Ellen Thompson. Ellen
went to Iowa and m 2nd Rev. Warren Rogers. Their son Benoni Hutchinson went
to Tuscola Co, MI.

I am anxious to find other descendants of this David Hutchinson, and to
learn more about Hannah Comstock. Thank you. Zelda. rvdubel@msn.com

Birth	27 Mar 1772	Smithfield, Providence County, Rhode Island
Marriage	Ca 1795	Rhode Island - David Hutchinson

Spouse	David Hutchinson (1770 - 1853)
Child	David Hutchinson (1799 - 1885)

Father	Ezekiel Comstock (1733 - 1777)
Mother	Mary Brayton (1744 - 1815)
Sibling	Henry Comstock (1767 - 1848)
Sibling	Waite Comstock (1769 - 1820)
Sibling	Phebe Comstock (1777 - 1778)