| Father | Sylvanus Brimhall Jr. (1786 - 1856) |
| Mother | Lydia Guitteau (1785 - 1843) |
| Sibling | Horace Johnson Brimhall (1809 - 1882) |
| Sibling | Nancy G. Brimhall (1811 - 1860) |
| Sibling | Mary Brimhall (1812 - 1899) |
| Sibling | George Washington Brimhall (1814 - 1895) |
| Sibling | Tryphena Brimhall (1816 - 1869) |
| Sibling | Norman Guitteau Brimhall (1820 - 1907) |
| Sibling | Sylvanus Brimhall I (1822 - 1907) |
| Sibling | John Brimhall (1824 - 1906) |
| Sibling | Noah Brimhall (1826 - 1918) |
| Sibling | Andrew Jackson Brimhall (1827 - 1918) |
| Sibling | Samuel Brimhall (1819 - 1888) |