| Father | John Goodsell (1706 - 1763) |
| Mother | Mary Lewis (1706 - 1769) |
| Sibling | Hannah Goodsell (1726 - 1757) |
| Sibling | Mary Goodsell (1727 - 1759) |
| Sibling | John Jacob Goodsell (1730 - 1779) |
| Sibling | Thomas Goodsell (1731 - 1805) |
| Sibling | Sarah Goodsell (1734 - 1762) |
| Sibling | Epaphrad Goodsell (1735 - 1735) |
| Sibling | Abigail Goodsell (1737 - 1754) |
| Sibling | Huldah Goodsell (1740 - 1765) |
| Sibling | Epaphras Goodsell (1742 - 1791) |
| Sibling | Phebe (twin) Goodsell (1744 - 1744) |
| Sibling | Lt Lewis Goodsell (1744 - 1829) |
| Sibling | Samuel Goodsell (1746 - ) |
| Sibling | James Goodsell (1748 - 1748) |