| Father | Theron Aaron Plumb (1785 - 1864) |
| Mother | Harriet Merrill Merry (1785 - 1835) |
| Sibling | Mary Plumb (1814 - 1836) |
| Sibling | Francis Merrill Plumb (1806 - 1899) |
| Sibling | Col. Ralph Oberlin Plumb (1816 - 1903) |
| Sibling | Julius Ashtabula Plumb (1827 - ) |
| Sibling | Edward B Plumb (1822 - 1869) |
| Sibling | Elizabeth Plumb (1828 - ) |
| Sibling | Calvin C Plumb (1816 - 1840) |
| Sibling | Theron Calvin Plumb (1808 - 1838) |
| Sibling | Samuel Plumb (1812 - 1882) |
| Sibling | Elizabeth T. Plumb (1813 - ) |
| Sibling | Hiram Abiff Plumb (1820 - 1859) |
| Sibling | Martha Plumb (1808 - ) |