| Father | John Penoyer (1777 - 1831) |
| Mother | Elizabeth Wilkinson (1782 - 1850) |
| Sibling | Mary Jane Penoyer (1822 - 1889) |
| Sibling | Asahel W Penoyer , Esq. (1824 - 1869) |
| Sibling | Alvin Penoyer (1801 - 1879) |
| Sibling | George C Penoyer (1805 - 1870) |
| Sibling | Rev. Joseph Sterling Penoyer (1810 - 1885) |
| Sibling | Elizabeth E Penoyer (1813 - 1831) |
| Sibling | Rhoda M Penoyer (1815 - ) |
| Sibling | Ira Penoyer (1816 - 1817) |
| Sibling | Roxanna Penoyer (1818 - 1841) |
| Sibling | Sylvia Penoyer (1820 - 1846) |
| Sibling | Polly Amanda Penoyer (1826 - 1900) |
| Sibling | John Penoyer Jr. (1806 - 1880) |