| Father | Abel Butterfield (1742 - 1814) |
| Mother | Mercy Heald (1744 - 1826) |
| Sibling | Abel Butterfield (1767 - 1836) |
| Sibling | Thankful Butterfield (1774 - 1836) |
| Sibling | Lydia Butterfield (1778 - 1850) |
| Sibling | Abigail Butterfield (1780 - 1826) |
| Sibling | Zachariah Butterfield (1782 - 1866) |
| Sibling | Joseph Butterfield (1784 - ) |
| Sibling | Lucy Farnsworth Butterfield (1786 - 1850) |
| Sibling | Susanna Butterfield (1788 - 1850) |
| Sibling | Rachel Butterfield (1790 - ) |
| Sibling | Rebecca Butterfield (1793 - 1864) |
| Sibling | Josiah Butterfield (1795 - 1871) |