| Father | Adam Shufelt (1798 - ) |
| Mother | Samantha Abbott (1805 - ) |
| Sibling | Adam Shufelt (1835 - ) |
| Sibling | David A. Shufelt (1836 - ) |
| Sibling | Ambrose Shufelt (1837 - 1893) |
| Sibling | Julia Emily Shufelt (1838 - 1892) |
| Sibling | Sabrina A. Shufelt (1840 - ) |
| Sibling | Abraham Shufelt (1844 - 1919) |
| Sibling | Henry Shufelt (1844 - 1916) |
| Sibling | Sarah Jane Shufelt (1848 - 1937) |
| Sibling | Warren Wilkerson Shufelt (1849 - 1927) |
| Sibling | Franklin P. Shufelt (1851 - 1923) |
| Sibling | Elizabeth Jenneth Shufelt (1853 - 1934) |
| Sibling | Nancy Shufelt (1856 - ) |
| Sibling | Adella Salle Shufelt (1856 - 1898) |